So I decided to go through some of my old archives and found some great stuff you old guys might remember. This is going back to the mid-90s. Set the Wayback machine...
There were some girls who would share their feet on their own websites:
-Princess Natalie, a very sarcastic Republican girl who would take oddball pics of her own feet;
-Sweetpea, who would obscure her face but she had awesome long toes and great curves;
Barefootchick. Man, she was hot.
Barefoot Kitty. She would play in the snow.
Mericat: remember Mericat?
Sharon'sfeet.com.
Froggy, who wore lots of toerings.
Gemma, who had terrific nailbeds & pedicures.
There were guys who would go around and ask girls for pics of their feet. These guys were good:
-Feet 'N Soul/Joshfeet. He would visit college campuses, especially Bible colleges. Some of his girls had no problem making their emails public. He would shoot a lot in libraries, which of course we don't do now, for good reason. The girls were always smiling and having fun. In fact, some of the best smiles I've ever seen from spontaneous "hey can I take pics of your feet" kind of work. He was great.
-Foot Club, lots of outdoors shots.
-Footclub.tripod.com. He was all over the place. Great natural girls.
-There was a guy in New England who would take shots on college campuses and name the files after elements in Star Wars movies. Very pretty girls.
-And then there was the guy who would carry around handcuffs and ankle cuffs and talk the girls into posing with them in hogtied positions. The girls in these pics are laughing hysterically while lying on their stomach with their handcuffs padlocked to their ankle cuffs. Amazing how he did that, talk about big balls.
-CCDude/Planet Trample...or were those two different things? Random girls in bars standing on Bob. Occasionally kissing each other's feet. RIP, Bob...
-Amazonsinthongs.com, which may have been partly a models site.
-The Barefoot Showcase, another guy taking great natural pics of everyday pretty girls having fun posing their feet.
Other vintage goodies including CA Beach Feet, Feetfair, Chromelady, Fabulous Feet Productions, Foot-Alarm, Footjoycove, extremefeet.com, footparadise.com, islandfeet, Footography.web1000.com, Spreadingtoes, BeautifulEverydayGirls, sockemadchen.de.